Over the last 12 months I've seen 56 movies that were released in the good ol' USA in 2008. That's far less than
your average
respected film critic, but I try to weed out the atrocious movies (
Step Up 2: The Streets,
The Hottie and the Nottie, etc.) so I believe I have a firm grasp on some of the best films that came out. In case you don't believe me, here are the ten I liked the most!
Brian's Top 10 Favorite Movies of 2008:
Close Calls: The Fall,
In Bruges,
The Wrestler
10. Profit Motive and the Whispering WindI found out about this movie from none other than Neil Young, who had it as his #2 film of the year. It's highly pretentious, but done in a heartfelt way. It basically attempts to tell the history of the United States through grave stones and memorial sites. It's not a traditional documentary however, as there is no dialogue until the film's climax.
9. WALL-EPixar always seems like they're able to outdo themselves, and while I liked
Ratatouille a little more, this one will go down as their artistic achievement of the decade. It's a prime example of what is a
family film, and not children's movie promoted as one.
8. Burn After ReadingA lot of critics were thrown off by this movie, calling this Coen brothers flick a major step down from their best picture winning
No Country For Old Men. I don't understand that rationale, they've been doing their drama-comedy-drama-comedy pattern for over 20 years.
Burn After Reading happens to be one of the best dark comedies they've done, causing me to laugh out loud in the theater repeatedly (which is hard to do). While you can intelligently look at the comically grim film as a take on how society makes women feel about their body image, or how our government handles its state of affairs, the best gag comes from George Clooney's "invention" that should have come out of the mind of a perverted 13 year old boy. The second funniest film of the year, only beaten by...
7. Tropic ThunderAn onslaught of successful gag after successful gag, Ben Stiller's track record may be spotty (
Zoolander), but Stiller (with Justin Theroux and Etan Coen) crafted a perfect screenplay that lampoons actors, agents, rappers, drug addicts and writers. The package is further completed with successful comedic action sequences. Oh, and how about those great fake trailers?
6. Frost/NixonSure, Ron Howard and co. took some liberties with the actual historical events (and the postscript made the TV special seem much bigger than it actually was) but the play-turned-film was gripping, almost too much so for a movie that hits its dramatic heights from only conversations. Best ensemble cast of the year.
5. MilkThis could make a run at best ensemble cast of the year as well. Gus Van Sant was able to craft a bio-pic that wards off the cliches that sink its generic contemporaries (
Ray). It resonates with any minority, and in this era of hope from a new administration, its sad ending (that you already know) doesn't bog the film down, it works as a celebration of the pursuit of social justice.
4. ElegyFor unknown reasons, this drama staring Ben Kingsley, Penelope Cruz, and Dustin Hoffman seems to have fallen through the cracks of the public and academy. It's an uncompromising film for the 35 and over crowd that's meditative, intelligent and assured about a relationship that Kingsley has with one of his students (Cruz) that he telegraphs is doomed from the start. Things aren't always as easy as they seem.
3. RepriseA Norwegian drama about two young aspiring writers in their early 20's and where their paths lead them. I'll be lying if I said I wasn't biased towards this film being a young man in my early 20's who writes. The two friends, Erik and Phillip, are fleshed out through their friendship, love, grief, and rage. Naturalistic and affecting.
2. Rachel Getting MarriedAnne Hathaway, gives her career performance as woman (Kym) who has been in and out of rehab for the past 10 years and returns home for the week for her sister's wedding. The fantastic direction allows the movie to breathe, and the rhythm works as a great catalyst for the suburb acting.
1. 4 Months, 3 Weeks, 2 DaysThis Romanian film about a college student who assists her friend to arrange an illegal abortion in 1980's communist Romania is not for the faint of heart. It's a piece of art and emotionally draining, no film impacted me more this year which makes it an easy choice for number 1. It's pitch perfect with long takes and natural dialogue. It's a shame I hit my 2008 peak with a film that came out in January.
As For The Oscars...
Best Picture: Should Win: Milk
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
It's no surprise that
Slumdog Millionaire will win, having clinched this category since December.
Slumdog Millionaire was an exceptional mature fairy tale but I'm naturally inclined to love movies that face reality head on than ones that try to take you away from it.
Milk was a brilliant production with better acting and a better screenplay, however
Slumdog Millionaire had better cinematography and better...
Best Director: Should Win: Danny Boyle (
Slumdog Millionaire)
Will Win: Danny Boyle (
Slumdog Millionaire)
The hook for me for
Slumdog as how visually arresting it is, taking us from point to point with ease hosting vibrant color and grand scope.
Best Actor: Should Win: Sean Penn
Will Win: Sean Penn
Sean Penn was the early favorite but now it seems he's neck and neck with Rouke. I don't
think Penn would be that upset to lose to him, as he said on record that
The Wrestler "made him weep." I thought Rouke was exceptional, and being from Jersey I felt a special poignancy in the film, but I really believe Sean Penn gave the best performance of his career, miles above his Oscar winning turn in
Mystic River (which should have went to Bill Murray for
Lost In Translation).
Best Actress:Should Win: Anne Hathaway
Will Win: Kate Winslet
I love that Winslet is most likely finally going to win as she's possibly the premier actress of her generation, however I don't think
The Reader (or
Revolutionary Road, which I thought was dreadful) is as worthy for an Oscar as some of the other works. Meryl Streep gave the best performance in the actor-driven
Doubt, but I have to give my vote to Anne Hathaway in
Rachel Getting Married. The scene where she makes a toast to her bride-to-be sister was cringe inducing (in a great way), the most I felt emotionally in a film all year (aside from the last act of
Elegy).
Best Supporting Actor:Should Win: Robert Downey Jr.
Will Win: Heath Ledger

It's a nice shock to the system if a comic book character could win a Best Acting award, but
I feel comedy is always ignored by the Academy. And really, the funniest performance of the year deserves some kind of recognition. But this is easily the strongest category this year, and it's the first time I can remember thinking I would be happy if any of the nominees won the award. I know Heath has the sympathy vote, but if he
hadn't died I don't think he'd be the projected winner (though he would have surely still been nominated). Since the Oscars messed up
royally with ratings by not giving
The Dark Knight a Best Picture nomination, they'll have to make it up here by voting for Heath. If there is an upset, it would be most likely be Michael Shannon, who was the best thing in
Revolutionary Road.
Best Supporting Actress:Should Win: Penelope Cruz
Will Win: Penelope Cruz
This is the wild card category for the Big 6, since one Best Supporting Oscar usually goes to an underdog. Since Heath is such a lock, it's going to be here. A lot of people are saying it'll be Voila Davis who, while only in
Doubt for about 8 minutes, was able to out act Meryl Streep in an intensely emotional scene. My Woody Allen favoritism is making me lean towards Cruz for
Vicky Cristina Barcelona, the original front runner for this category.
Alright, I'm tired of writing, here are my other predictions with no commentary:
Best Adapted Screenplay:Should Win: Frost/Nixon
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Best Original Sreenplay: Should Win: In Bruges
Will Win: Milk
Best Cinematography: Should Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Best Foreign Language Film: Should Win: The Class
Will Win: Waltz with Bashir
Best Animated Feature: Should Win: WALL-E
Will Win: WALL-E
Best Foreign Language Film: Should Win: The Class
Will Win: Waltz with Bashir
Best Editing: Should Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Best Musical Score: Should Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Best Song:Should Win: "O Saya" from
Slumdog MillionaireWill Win: "Down to Earth" from
WALL-E 
(
Slumdog voters will be split)
Best Documentary: Should Win: Man on Wire
Will Win: Man on Wire
Best Makeup: Should Win: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Will Win: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Costume Design:Should Win: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Will Win: The Duchess
Art Direction:Should Win: The Dark Knight
Will Win: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Sound Editing:
Should Win: The Dark Knight
Will Win: The Dark Knight
Sound Mixing:Should Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Will Win: Slumdog Millionaire
Best Visual Effects:Should Win: The Dark Knight
Will Win: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
How will I do? We'll see Sunday night. Expect a rant.